• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Regency Romance Reviews

The review site for lovers of traditional Regency Romance books from Heyer to Smith and beyond

  • All Authors
  • Full list of all our reviews
  • Articles
  • About Book Addicts

Lady Cecily’s Scheme by Gayle Buck

Cover image of the Regency romance novel Lady Cecily's Scheme by Gayle Buck
Buy on Amazon

The blurb:

His disguise fooled everyone, even her.
Lady Cecily wants to live in London, not in the country. However, until her daughter weds, she is stuck; so Lady Cecily schemes to get Vanessa to the altar. Anyone will do! Miss Vanessa Lester is level-headed and heart-whole, until she comes face to face with a wounded smuggler. A moonlit night, the kiss of a handsome rogue, and her heart is lost.

Written by: Gayle Buck
First published: 2015

My thoughts

Hmm, what to say about this book? First up, I should mention that it is quite long – 260 pages – and yet most of the action, including the romance (!) doesn’t happen until the 70% mark.

So if you’re someone who prefers fast paced books, with lots of action, particularly the romantic type of action, then best to put this book back. But if you like slow-burn romance and a plot that’s driven by conversation (think Georgette Heyer or Joan Smith) then I think you’ll like Lady Cecily’s Scheme.

(Is this a good spot to point out that Lady C is actually not the heroine of this Regency romance? It’s a bit confusing I know but the heroine is actually her daughter Vanessa).

Anyway although Vanessa is young (only 19) she’s sensible and level-headed whilst I’d classify the hero as more of a gentle hero even though ultimately he does of course end up doing great, heroic deeds.

Gayle Buck’s writing can be deceiving – her style is so lyrical and yes, gentle and slow (again reminiscent of Heyer and Smith) that I keep thinking her books are from quite a few years (if not decades) ago. Lady Cecily’s Scheme was first published in 2015 though which I guess explains why Vanessa not only starts out as a sensible woman, but stays sensible even after she falls in love.

I can’t abide those heroines who start out as independent, capable women and then somehow can’t even think for themselves after ‘the romance’ hits them. There’s a great bit in this book where Vanessa is in danger, but no… no more otherwise ‘spoilers sweetie’. You’ll just have to read it to find out what I mean.

There are a few typos and grammatical errors – I particularly love how France became Prance, adding a bit of unexpected levity to an otherwise serious scene. But these were small and didn’t detract from my overall enjoyment of the book. I don’t think they’ll diminish anyone else’s enjoyment either.

Ultimately though I guess you want to know – did I feel the HEA was right? Was I left with a warm and fuzzy feeling or wishing I could get my money back?

Yes, I do think the HEA was right. I can see Vanessa and her hero settling down quite nicely into a marriage that is founded on respect, friendship and equal contributions by both partners.

Whilst I don’t think I was left with a particularly warm and fuzzy feeling thanks to the shortened period in which the actual romance took place, I definitely don’t want my money back. I’ve re-read this book quite a few times and continue to enjoy it every time I read it.

Ultimately this is a Recommend from me and if you’re interested in trying it out you can buy Lady Cecily’s Scheme here on Amazon.

Want to find other books like this one?

Click a theme: Mystery, Nice guy heroes, Recommended, Smart heroines Click an author's name: Gayle Buck, Joan Smith

Subscribe to my monthly newsletter and get honest, useful reviews of Regency Romance novels so that you can stop wasting money and time and start reading more of the books you actually like.
* indicates required

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to my monthly newsletter and get honest, useful reviews of Regency Romance novels so that you can stop wasting money and time and start reading more of the books you actually like.
* indicates required

Looking for more reviews?

The full list of all my reviews is available here.

The full list of all the authors I’ve reviewed is here.

Browse by Genres

  • Alpha male
  • Christmas
  • Cinderella story
  • False marriage / Marriage of convenience
  • Humourous
  • Nice guy heroes
  • Mystery
  • Novella / Short Story
  • Older heroine
  • Reunited lovers / Second chance for love
  • Smart heroines
  • Some Sizzle
  • Witty Banter

Browse by Recommendations

  • Highly Recommended
  • Recommended
  • Not Recommended
Professional Reader

I acknowledge the Awabakal people as the traditional custodians of the land on which I live and pay my respects to their Elders, past, present and emerging

Copyright © 2022